• About Me
  • Disclosure
  • Shop

Making Cents Matter

  • Home
  • Resource Library
  • Budget
    • Budgeting Tips
    • Our Monthly Budget
    • Meal Planning
    • Free Printables
  • Debt Free
    • Debt Free Tips
    • Our Debt Free Journey
    • Free Printables
  • Saving
    • Ways We Save
    • DIY
    • Free Printables
  • Recipes
    • Recipes
      • Breakfast
      • Lunch
      • Dinners
      • Instant Pot
      • Slow Cooker
      • Soups
    • Meal Planning
    • Preserving Food
  • Garden
    • Gardening Tips
    • Preserving Food
  • Shop

July 14, 2017 · Leave a Comment

Our 30 Day Experiment with Cash Envelopes

This post may contain affiliate links for your convenience.
Click here to read my disclosure policy.

Budget· Budget Tips

0shares

Some of you may be shocked right now.  I mean, it’s no secret that I’m not much of a cash envelope fan.  While it is the one thing that most budgets have in common, we’ve been able to pay off nearly $75,000 in debt without using cash envelopes, and just using our debit card.

Why am I not much of a fan?  Well, for starters, I never knew what to take out for each category.  It seemed simpler to use our debit card so I only had one thing to keep track of, and just keep our groceries under a set amount each week.

Besides, we’ve never spent the same amount of money month to month, or even week to week, on groceries.  And we can just forget about household items.  What we spend fluxuates each month based on our needs, or how fast my kids are growing and eating me out of house and home.

I honestly felt that to limit myself to a specific amount of cash was also, well, inconvenient.

Cash Envelopes

Why We Didn’t Use Cash Envelopes Before

The biggest reason it took me so long to make the switch to cash envelopes was that I cannot go to our bank and take out cash.   There is no physical building of our credit union anywhere near us.  The closest bank location is 70 miles away, while the nearest ATM is an hour drive away.  Nope.

On the plus side, they do work with some ATMs that are in a certain network so I don’t get charged when I do withdrawal money.  There are some of these ATMs in my relative area.  I say relative because there are a total of four of them within a half hour drive.  As I drive to these specific ATMs, I pass a bazillion others in the process, all of which charge me a minimum of $3 each time I take out money.  Annoying and inconvenient.

{I do have to point out that this charge is reimbursed by the bank, but not until the first of the following month, potentially leaving me out a minimum of $12 if I were to withdrawal cash each pay period.  That’s about the cost of our weekend newspaper subscription.}

And then I do get to such ATMs that I am not charged for withdrawing my money from, I can only take out in multiples of $20s.  All those other bazillion ATMs I had to pass on the way?  In multiples of $10s or $5s.  What’s up with that?

I cannot go to the ATM and say “Can I have that in $50s, $20s and $1s, please?”

Now, if you’re like me, you’re probably thinking “what about taking it as cash back during a purchase?”   And you are absolutely right!  I mean, Target, Walmart, and my local grocery stores let you take cash out at the end of your purchase.  I’ve been able to do it before for things where cash is the only currency they accept, like the occasional haircut, for the farmer’s market, or money for our local ice cream store {mmmmm!}.

Well, did you know some stores have limits on how much cash you can take out per day?  I didn’t until I tried.  Yes, I separated out my Target cart into multiple transactions thinking I could get out more cash.  Failure.  So if I’m trying to take $160 out in cash for the grocery store, it’ll take me 4 days.  Again, inconvenient.

So what was stopping me from spending a month to experiment with cash?  Absolutely nothing.  Besides my own stubbornness of course!

Our Experiment With Cash

Our experiment started because what we were spending on groceries each week was getting out of control.  I had spent the entire month of May running between soccer, band performances and medical appointments.  Our grocery spending was the furthest thing from my mind.  When all was said and done, we spent over $850 on groceries in May, and I needed to get that amount back under control so I could get more of our money towards paying off debt.

What I learned right away is this: paying in cash has a really big advantage because it’s very visual.

This is the reason to use cash.  Some will tell you that it “hurts”.  Not for me.  What hurts is continuing to lug around our debt.  What doesn’t hurt is knowing I only have $50 left in grocery money until next payday, so I better make that stretch.

Think of cash envelopes like a visual inventory of your debit card.  Rather than being left with the last imprint of your account balance, you have a real-time update of what is left.  It helps prevent those times you forget to subtract your debit purchases from that account balance you looked up previously.  You can physically see how much you have left in specific categories, whether it’s for groceries or for Starbucks.

Now don’t get me wrong, I still loathe the thought of having to get everyone out of the car in the middle of February in snow, ice and negative temperatures just to pay cash for fuel.

So over the last 30 days, I have come up with certain categories where I will still continue to swipe my debit card.  This includes fuel, birthday & holiday expenses, and our purchases from Target {I really do enjoy the 5% off as it offsets sales tax}.

But for some other items, like groceries, household goods, toiletries, garden items, personal spending money, kids spending money, eating out, clothing and so on…. you know, those little things that can add up so fast without realizing it every time you swipe your card… I’ll be using cash from here on out.

And about that previously thought inconvenience?  Not anymore.  What is inconvenient and annoying is consistently overspending, and not being able to put as much on our debts as we would like to.

Have you made the switch to using cash envelopes for purchases?  Was the transition easier than you thought, or harder?  What categories do you use?  I’d love to hear in the comments below!

Related Posts

  • Carrot Squash SoupCarrot Squash Soup
  • How To Make Instant Pot Chicken BrothHow To Make Instant Pot Chicken Broth
  • October & November 2017 Debt UpdateOctober & November 2017 Debt Update
  • Homemade Condensed Cream Of SoupHomemade Condensed Cream Of Soup
  • 9 Simple Steps To Pay Off Debt9 Simple Steps To Pay Off Debt
  • October Budget CategoriesOctober Budget Categories
0shares
Previous Post: « June 2017 Debt Update
Next Post: Berry Coconut Crumble Bars »

Reader Interactions

Want access to our resource library? Sign up for our free email list!

* indicates required

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badgeShow more posts

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • YouTube

Post Categories





makingcentsmatter

makingcentsmatter
Payday is today! Actually, payday was Friday the 1 Payday is today! Actually, payday was Friday the 12th because we completely forgot today is a bank holiday in the US. The feeling of being paid and not needing it is a nice one.⁠
.⁠
Here's what our paycheck needs to get us through for bills until March 14th. For a full look at our budget over the next month, head over to my budget with me on YouTube: https://youtu.be/rb8uyi1-rNc⁠
.⁠
.⁠
.⁠
.⁠
.⁠
.⁠
.⁠
.⁠
.⁠
#monthlyincome #monthlybudget #monthlybudget #zerobasedbudget #payday #budgetwithme #budgeting #budgettips #budgetcalendar #frugalliving #savingmoney #paycheck #makingcentsmatter #debtfreejourney #debtfreeprogress
This weekend was focused on a pantry shop and meal This weekend was focused on a pantry shop and meal plan creation! This meal plan to get us to our February payday. We also picked fast meals, because it's a busy two weeks between doctor's appointments,. Academic Decathalon, dance, and drama. I'm unsure we'll be able to shop on payday, hence the extras.⁠
.⁠
Total spent: $112.39 for items to get us through this and lunches.⁠
.⁠
Keep in mind, just over $112 for 12 meals isn't sustainable for our family, just in times when we need to stretch the last bits of our monthly income. I really wish $112 was enough to feed two teenaged boys in our household.⁠
.⁠
The point being... do what works for you, and your situation based on your location. Don't try to fit yourself into someone else's situation!⁠
.⁠
#mealplan #mealplanning #frugalliving #frugalmom #makingcentsmatter #savingmoney #monthlyincome #budgeting #budgetmom #groceryshop
January's real numbers:⁠ .⁠ House: $511.13⁠ January's real numbers:⁠
.⁠
House: $511.13⁠
Citi: $720⁠
D NelNet: $100⁠
K NelNet: $100⁠
K Chase: $150⁠
Explorer: $343⁠
.⁠
Extra Payment to Citi: $500⁠
.⁠
Noteworthy... our car payment had a late fee assessed because the mail was SLOWED down over Christmas. Three headaches later, and we potentially have online banking finally set up with them. It is still a headache. And we are never taking another car loan out with this bank!⁠
.⁠
How was January?⁠
.⁠
#makingcentsmatter #debt #debtfreejouney #debtfreeprogress #debtfreecommunity #realbudget #savingmoney #savings #frugalliving #frugalblogging #budgeting #monthlyincome #zerobasedbudget #financialgoals #personalfinance #personalfinancetips #financialfreedom
Sometimes in order to see progress, you need to ta Sometimes in order to see progress, you need to take a step back.
.
I'll be honest, I didn't think that we got this far in 2020. With everything going on - and more importantly, everything NOT going on - we didn't keep up with this every month. We just threw what we could at our goal. I'm simply amazed at how far we came.
.
Things are still hectic, and I'm simply mentally exhausted between remote learning, extended remote learning, offset quarantining children... it goes on and on.
.
But I also cannot wait to see what strides we will make in 2021.
.
#makingcentsmatter #debtfreejouney #debtfreeprogress #savingmoney #savings #frugalliving #frugalblogging #budgeting #monthlyincome #zerobasedbudget #financialgoals #personalfinance
This is what school looks like when it's a hybrid This is what school looks like when it's a hybrid model, and your house does not have unlimited space. I was standing in our kitchen when I took this picture, the kids behind me making lunch.
.
Our district is carefully monitoring our local infection rates, and we are currently in a hybrid form. That means they divided the district into two groups; half are in school on Monday and Tuesday, the other half on Thursday and Friday. They are offering an all remote option, but Verizon for some reason supplies our house with speeds so slow that it would shock a tortoise. Remote was a no-go.
.
This set-up has taken some trial and error to get to where we currently are. Because no matter how prepared you are and how much you've planned, once you're in the weeds, actually doing it, there is no telling how your best-laid plans will work.
.
Our home is a 1800sqft one-story, open living area, 4 bedroom, 1 bathroom, ranch-style house in a very rural area. It has no home offices. No guest bedrooms. Yes, that is a desk in the corner of our dining room. 🤣
.
Each kid gets their own color bin for their school work. This includes school-issued Chromebooks and other standard items they need to get work done - headphones, pencils, and so on. When we are done for the day, we clean up everything, place them neatly in these bins, and place them in cubbies (on my current left) at night while the Chromebooks charge.
.
I do NOT bother to clean up at lunchtime. It would take us more time to clean up and reset everything than it takes us to eat lunch. So we only pack it all up for the day and call it done.
.
During the day, I sit between my younger two and field any questions they may have, troubleshoot technical issues we all have, and be the overall bouncer when things get off-topic. My high schooler will occasionally emerge from his bedroom, which opens to the kitchen. So he is close by when he has questions.
.
Please remember that with all things in life, you need to work with what's available to you. And there is no shame in that. Don't ever feel like you're not doing good enough because it's not picture perfect. Work with what you have available to you, and you'll do amazing things.
School is in session, the garden is slowing, and I School is in session, the garden is slowing, and I’ve finally realized I haven’t shared our payoff numbers for July or August. Yeah……
.
Please keep in mind, we are paid monthly on the 15th, but we don’t go by a “monthly” budget. So I have to go back and look at these numbers based off their due dates in the calendar. Because our pay falls in the middle of the month, I can’t tell you what portion of our income went to debt. It’s going to vary paycheck to paycheck anyways because our priorities vary with each check. Nothing is ever the same month to month, and pay to pay.
.
That said, inJuly we paid off $2,694.43.
In August we paid off $1,673.40.
.
The difference here is that our priorities shifted between the two months.
.
During August, we were doing more prep for whatever school would look like this year, and we had some savings goals make their way to the top of the list as well.
.
Of those goals, in August we made progress!
EF Reimbursement: $146 / $1,200
Checking Buffer Reimbursement: $227 / $500
Vet Sinking Fund: $40 / $200
.
Remember this is a journey, not a race. There is no point wearing yourself ragged and still making no progress. Make progress where you can, and celebrate it. Even if it’s $5.
.
It’s progress, and that’s what matters!
While I wait for the canner to finish the last rou While I wait for the canner to finish the last round... I rearranged our recipe binder. It's only taken me 8 or so years. 🤣😶😭
.
I miss the days when zucchini was my problem. Now it's tomatoes. I can only find so many ways to use up spaghetti sauce! So the next 50lbs or so will be chili base and unseasoned sauce.
.
On top of this school is starting with a hybrid in building & online system. And I'm seriously slacking on some things I need to do. I'm not good at juggling multiple things and the balls are falling. But I keep reminding myself... be patient. This too shall pass. This is only a phase. So I pick and choose what's the most important, focus on that and go from there.
.
So if you feel overwhelmed with your current phase, remember, this too shall pass. It's okay to rearrange priorities. It's okay to take a breather.
.
This too shall pass.
If you didn't start finding interesting ways to ge If you didn't start finding interesting ways to get rid of the squash, can you say you even planted any?
.
Good news, I'm almost caught up! Bad news, the garden has more.
Super busy here... but I wanted to share that wins Super busy here... but I wanted to share that wins can come in super small packages. I thought I'd spend $380 to clean the band instruments in this house. I ended up spending $234. So the remaining $146 can go to reimbursing what I pulled from our EF.
.
No matter the win, celebrate it!
.
What are some wins you have had lately?
Load More... Follow on Instagram


Copyright

I love it when you share our content! Please keep in mind that all content, images and text on this site are property of Making Cents Matter. Feel free to use no more than two photos on your own site, provided that a link back to my original post is included. Do not crop, edit, or remove any watermarks from any of my images without obtaining written permission from me first. Thank you!

Privacy Policy & Disclosures

MakingCentsMatter is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and other affiliated sites.

You can read more about our privacy policy and disclosures here.

Copyright © 2021 · Captivating Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in