• About Me
  • Disclosure
  • Shop

Making Cents Matter

  • Home
  • Resource Library
  • Budget
    • Budgeting Tips
    • Our Monthly Budget
    • Meal Planning
    • Free Printables
  • Debt Free
    • Debt Free Tips
    • Our Debt Free Journey
    • Free Printables
  • Saving
    • Ways We Save
    • DIY
    • Free Printables
  • Recipes
    • Recipes
      • Breakfast
      • Lunch
      • Dinners
      • Instant Pot
      • Slow Cooker
      • Soups
    • Meal Planning
    • Preserving Food
  • Garden
    • Gardening Tips
    • Preserving Food
  • Shop

January 5, 2016 · 6 Comments

Homemade Vanilla Yogurt

This post may contain affiliate links for your convenience.
Click here to read my disclosure policy.

Breakfast· Frugal Living· Recipes

317shares
  • 317
Homemade Vanilla Yogurt

When I started making cuts from my grocery bill, yogurts were one item that stuck around.  Homemade yogurt was far from my mind.  I’m not a big fan of yogurt in general, but Hubs and the kids eat them with lunch.  The kids preferred the name brand, and I was easily able to get them for $0.50 per cup or less.  Sometimes I got them as low as $0.39 per cup.  So I continued to buy them.  The thing is, even at $0.39 per cup, that’s nearly $12 of yogurts to get everyone through a week.  I had to start finding a new way.

Homemade Vanilla Yogurt

Homemade Vanilla Yogurt

At Hubs’ request, I started buying a quart of vanilla yogurt at $4 per quart.  It helped reduce what we spent each week.  Then the kids would start eating from Hubs’ yogurt stash, and I’d wind up buying 2 quarts per week.  I had a light bulb moment.  I starting looking up how to make our own yogurt.

I was really skeptical at first, because I’ve heard how hard it is, how time consuming it can be, and how it doesn’t turn out like the stuff in the store you’re used to.  My fear of screwing up a batch kept me from doing it for a while actually.

After a few tries I’ve learned a few things:

  • Homemade yogurt NOT as hard as you’d think.  I haven’t screwed it up yet {and that’s saying something because I’ve forgotten I had it heating in the crock pot and Lady Bug and I got lost in the garden}.
  • It does take a long time from start to finish, BUT the majority of it is hands off time.  I start it at 2 pm that way I’m adding in the starter around bedtime, and the yogurt is ready to go at 6 am when I’m packing lunches.
  • You can use Lactaid, but it’ll come out really, really sweet.  I then tried it with regular milk, and my kids have handled it just fine so far, including Lady Bug who can’t even drink Lactaid.  Bonus in that a half gallon of milk is $1.45 cheaper than a half gallon of Lactaid.
  • You can leave out the ClearJel and strain the yogurt in cheesecloth if you like a thicker yogurt.  I don’t like to do that for a few reasons.  1} Who has that kind of time?  2}  I know how well I operate cheesecloth for canning recipes.  Can we say cleanup in aisle 9?  3} I want to get my money’s worth from the milk, so I’d rather have a large, thick batch of yogurt than a smaller batch as well as some milk.  And finally, 4} I don’t mind a thickener in my yogurt; take a look at Stoneyfield’s ingredients.  Yes, pectin is there.

The best part of all is that it’s really hard to screw up.  I’ve done some doozies with this, and it still comes out edible!

 

So how does it stack up?

A half gallon of milk yields 2 quarts and 2 cups of yogurt for me.  It’s enough for a week worth of yogurt between 4 people, and starter for the following week.  The only thing I have to buy is the milk; all other ingredients I have on hand.  A half gallon of whole milk costs $1.84.  To have a week worth of yogurt in the store bought quarts, I’d have to pay $7.58.  That’s a $5.74 savings, or 76%!

 

INGREDIENTS:

  • 1 half gallon whole milk
  • 1/2 cup sugar
  • 3 Tablespoons ClearJel*
  • 1 Tablespoon vanilla
  • 6-8 ounces vanilla starter {I just used a cup of Stoneyfield Vanilla Yogurt since that’s what I was buying by the quart at the time}

DIRECTIONS

  1. Spray slow cooker liner with cooking spray.
  2. Pour milk into the slow cooker.  Heat on low for 2 hours 45 minutes.
  3. When time is up, combine sugar and ClearJel* in a separate bowl.  Whisk sugar mixture and vanilla into heated milk.
  4. Cover, and let it sit for 3 hours.
  5. When time is up, using a 2 cup measuring cup, whisk together 1 cup of the milk mixture and the yogurt starter.  Pour this mixture into the slow cooker and whisk together.  Cover, and wrap the slow cooker with two kitchen towels.  {I like to use a smaller one for the top and a larger one for around the sides.}  Let sit, undisturbed in a warm place for 8 – 12 hours.
  6. When the time is up, transfer your yogurt into food safe containers and store in the fridge.  I love using empty mason jars.

Homemade Vanilla Yogurt 3

Notes:

  • Spraying the liner with cooking spray may be an entirely optional step.  I do this because I know my crockpot, and if I skip this step, it’s a huge mess for me later on.
  • I use ClearJel because I have it on hand from canning apples this summer.  It’s just corn starch that’s safe for higher temperatures that happen in the canner.  I’ve used corn starch with excellent results as well.  I plan on trying with Arrowroot Powder in the future.  The trick is to combine it with the sugar to make sure it doesn’t clump.

Have you tried making your own yogurt?  Will you give it a try now that you know how easy it is?

Related Posts

  • How One Phone Call Saved Me $170How One Phone Call Saved Me $170
  • Zero Based BudgetZero Based Budget
  • Five Money Saving Apps You NeedFive Money Saving Apps You Need
  • Chocolate Chip Banana Bread BarsChocolate Chip Banana Bread Bars
  • How To Complete A Budget ReviewHow To Complete A Budget Review
  • Lasagna Stuffed ShellsLasagna Stuffed Shells
317shares
  • 317
Previous Post: « January 2016 Budget
Next Post: 6 Ways to Increase Debt Payment »

Reader Interactions

Want access to our resource library? Sign up for our free email list!

* indicates required

Comments

  1. Nancy says

    May 15, 2019 at 9:26 pm

    When you say Vanilla starter, is that just store bought yogurt? I’m a newbie at the diy yogurt game.

    Reply
    • Kate says

      June 10, 2019 at 7:59 pm

      Hi Nancy! Yes it is! I buy a 6oz container of yogurt as the starter for the initial batch, and then use about 6oz from that first batch to make the second batch, and so on.

      Reply
  2. Hilary says

    March 18, 2020 at 11:49 am

    When it sets for the 3 hours does the crockpot need to be off?

    Reply
    • Kate says

      March 19, 2020 at 8:44 pm

      Hi Hilary! Yes, the crockpot does need to be off, otherwise, it’ll burn. Hope that helps!

      Kate

      Reply
  3. Tiffany says

    November 20, 2020 at 7:17 am

    Hi! I’m planning to try this with soy milk, does your yogurt typically end up being pretty close to store bought consistency in thickness? Hoping the soy milk won’t mess it up too much…

    Reply
    • Kate says

      January 7, 2021 at 4:00 pm

      I don’t know how this would come out with soy milk; I’ve never tried it. It does come out a little sweeter than storebought when we use lactaid though.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badgeShow more posts

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • YouTube





makingcentsmatter

This is what school looks like when it's a hybrid This is what school looks like when it's a hybrid model, and your house does not have unlimited space. I was standing in our kitchen when I took this picture, the kids behind me making lunch.
.
Our district is carefully monitoring our local infection rates, and we are currently in a hybrid form. That means they divided the district into two groups; half are in school on Monday and Tuesday, the other half on Thursday and Friday. They are offering an all remote option, but Verizon for some reason supplies our house with speeds so slow that it would shock a tortoise. Remote was a no-go.
.
This set-up has taken some trial and error to get to where we currently are. Because no matter how prepared you are and how much you've planned, once you're in the weeds, actually doing it, there is no telling how your best-laid plans will work.
.
Our home is a 1800sqft one-story, open living area, 4 bedroom, 1 bathroom, ranch-style house in a very rural area. It has no home offices. No guest bedrooms. Yes, that is a desk in the corner of our dining room. 🤣
.
Each kid gets their own color bin for their school work. This includes school-issued Chromebooks and other standard items they need to get work done - headphones, pencils, and so on. When we are done for the day, we clean up everything, place them neatly in these bins, and place them in cubbies (on my current left) at night while the Chromebooks charge.
.
I do NOT bother to clean up at lunchtime. It would take us more time to clean up and reset everything than it takes us to eat lunch. So we only pack it all up for the day and call it done.
.
During the day, I sit between my younger two and field any questions they may have, troubleshoot technical issues we all have, and be the overall bouncer when things get off-topic. My high schooler will occasionally emerge from his bedroom, which opens to the kitchen. So he is close by when he has questions.
.
Please remember that with all things in life, you need to work with what's available to you. And there is no shame in that. Don't ever feel like you're not doing good enough because it's not picture perfect. Work with what you have available to you, and you'll do amazing things.
School is in session, the garden is slowing, and I School is in session, the garden is slowing, and I’ve finally realized I haven’t shared our payoff numbers for July or August. Yeah……
.
Please keep in mind, we are paid monthly on the 15th, but we don’t go by a “monthly” budget. So I have to go back and look at these numbers based off their due dates in the calendar. Because our pay falls in the middle of the month, I can’t tell you what portion of our income went to debt. It’s going to vary paycheck to paycheck anyways because our priorities vary with each check. Nothing is ever the same month to month, and pay to pay.
.
That said, inJuly we paid off $2,694.43.
In August we paid off $1,673.40.
.
The difference here is that our priorities shifted between the two months.
.
During August, we were doing more prep for whatever school would look like this year, and we had some savings goals make their way to the top of the list as well.
.
Of those goals, in August we made progress!
EF Reimbursement: $146 / $1,200
Checking Buffer Reimbursement: $227 / $500
Vet Sinking Fund: $40 / $200
.
Remember this is a journey, not a race. There is no point wearing yourself ragged and still making no progress. Make progress where you can, and celebrate it. Even if it’s $5.
.
It’s progress, and that’s what matters!
While I wait for the canner to finish the last rou While I wait for the canner to finish the last round... I rearranged our recipe binder. It's only taken me 8 or so years. 🤣😶😭
.
I miss the days when zucchini was my problem. Now it's tomatoes. I can only find so many ways to use up spaghetti sauce! So the next 50lbs or so will be chili base and unseasoned sauce.
.
On top of this school is starting with a hybrid in building & online system. And I'm seriously slacking on some things I need to do. I'm not good at juggling multiple things and the balls are falling. But I keep reminding myself... be patient. This too shall pass. This is only a phase. So I pick and choose what's the most important, focus on that and go from there.
.
So if you feel overwhelmed with your current phase, remember, this too shall pass. It's okay to rearrange priorities. It's okay to take a breather.
.
This too shall pass.
If you didn't start finding interesting ways to ge If you didn't start finding interesting ways to get rid of the squash, can you say you even planted any?
.
Good news, I'm almost caught up! Bad news, the garden has more.
Super busy here... but I wanted to share that wins Super busy here... but I wanted to share that wins can come in super small packages. I thought I'd spend $380 to clean the band instruments in this house. I ended up spending $234. So the remaining $146 can go to reimbursing what I pulled from our EF.
.
No matter the win, celebrate it!
.
What are some wins you have had lately?
In total we have 15lbs green beans, 10lbs cucumber In total we have 15lbs green beans, 10lbs cucumbers, 5lbs blueberries, and countless zucchini and squash with more on the way! My weekend is spoken for... and this isn't all of it. 😳
Rather than looking back through all our non-month Rather than looking back through all our non-monthly bills for the year and try to remember what I paid and when I paid it, I make a note of how much it was on our bill pay tracker. That way I can easily tally it up at the end of the year, set our sinking funds next year accordingly, and not spend more time than is necessary on this... because kids and all.⁣
.⁣
Anyone else do this? Do you have a different method of tracking these expenses?⁣
.⁣
This particular printable is in my Etsy shop here: https://www.etsy.com/shop/MakingCentsMatter⁣
It's also part of my budgeting workbook, also in my Etsy shop.⁣
Good news though... there's a very similar free version in my resource library as well. Links are in my profile.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
⁣
#budget #budgeting #sinkingfund #savingmoney #savings  #cashbudget #cash #cashisking #frugalblogger #frugalmom #frugalliving #financialgoals #budgetprintable #personalfinancetips  #personalfinance #debtfreejourney #debtfreecommunity #debtfreeprogress #bs1 #bs2 #bs3  #makingcentsmatter #financialfreedom #debtfree
Probably an unpopular opinion here... but these tw Probably an unpopular opinion here... but these two things are NOT the same to me.⁣
.⁣
𝗟𝗶𝘃𝗶𝗻𝗴 paycheck to paycheck means that you're using all of your money for expenses with none left over for savings. This usually happens when you're not aware of where you are spending your money, and how much you are spending. For us, this happened in the form of those tiny expenses that can add up to even larger expenses, and then an unexpected bill comes and you have nothing left to cover it.⁣
.⁣
𝗕𝘂𝗱𝗴𝗲𝘁𝗶𝗻𝗴 paycheck to paycheck means that you are giving every single cent you earn a job to do that aligns with your priorities - like in sinking funds, savings, expenses, debt payments, etc - until the next paycheck. You have the money on hand to cover some unexpected expenses, and you are mindful of your spending so that you're not leaking money through small purchases.⁣
.⁣
This doesn't mean that there still aren't bad months. Murphy's Law does happen. But you are aware of the spending, aware of the priorities, and where your money needs to be allocated.⁣
.⁣
So... just because you're budgeting paycheck to paycheck doesn't mean you're living paycheck to paycheck.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.
June's paycheck was a doozy! I haven't looked forw June's paycheck was a doozy! I haven't looked forward to a paycheck since we first made the switch to monthly pays. It was so bad we've got a new order to things.⁣
.⁣
Good news is that if our state keeps closing things down, we should hammer this out in no time!⁣
.⁣
To see the full breakdown of how bad June's paycheck was, check out the June 15th Budget Review on our YouTube channel here https://youtu.be/gXoEo33hIYQ. Link is also in the bio.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.⁣
.
Load More... Follow on Instagram


Gymboree Sale On Now!

Copyright

I love it when you share our content! Please keep in mind that all content, images and text on this site are property of Making Cents Matter. Feel free to use no more than two photos on your own site, provided that a link back to my original post is included. Do not crop, edit, or remove any watermarks from any of my images without obtaining written permission from me first. Thank you!

Copyright © 2021 · Captivating Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in